Strange isn't it? Let's look at the press release:
"The blonde 19-year-old was dancing with Charley and Nicky in the living room of the Big Brother house at approximately 8.30pm last night when she was heard to say "Are you pushing it out you n*****?" to Charley".
Er. No she wasn't. They were in the garden and they weren't dancing, they were sitting down smoking. Why the mistake?
And why did it take so long to sort out? Why was Emily suddenly called to the diary room at 3.30 a.m. seven hours after the event? Why wasn't she just whisked to the diary room, reprimanded, given a formal warning, or even removed? Why for that matter, didn't they wait till she had woken up? It's a bit like a policeman watching a burglary take place, and calling the station to ask what he should do.
But I think a lot is explained when you realise what's going on behind the scenes. The real battle going on in this isn't Emily versus Charley, nor is it about racism. It's about Endemol against Channel Four. Endemol, who make the programme, wanted to settle this inside the house. This, after all, is the whole point of the show. We the audience weigh all this up. We see how the housemates get on, we see their good and bad points and make assessments every Friday as to who we want in. But Channel Four, the broadcasters, were having none of this. Having been stung by CBB, they went ballistic, and ordered her out.
Clearly this event sent the production team into panic. You can imagine the phone calls and meetings, which is why nobody did the decent thing and called Emily into the diary room. They were too busy panicking. Which is why they couldn't even get the basic facts right in their press release.
Meanwhile Charley did all she can to draw attention to it all. It's a bit like in a football match when somebody fouls someone. A dozen others pile in just to make sure the ref does something. And the ref usually does. But he never sends everybody off, and always picks the initial offender. Cristiano Ronaldo versus Wayne Rooney, anyone?
But perhaps Charley was offended, and I'm being unfair. But she kept saying she wasn't, and that she knew Emily didn't mean anything by it. So why did she make sure Laura, then Shabnam, and finally anyone who was awake in the bedroom hear all about it? Yes, she's a mouthy girl, and keeping a secret doesn't seem to be one of her talents.
I do wonder, though, what would have happened if the three of them had decided, genuinely, to let it lie, and if the whole incident had blown over in half a minute, and none of them referred to it ever again.
It would have been nice if Charley and Nicky had just told her she was out of order, don't do it again, but we don't believe you meant it maliciously, so let's just leave it. And left it. But I guess I'm asking too much.
Still, rules is rules, and I think you could guage from their reaction that they had all been heavily primed that any use of the n-word meant you were out on your ear. They all knew the significance of it, and knew what was coming. That's why they were all so excitable. They knew.
But dragging someone out of bed in the middle of the night? Cruel.
Still, it's over and done with. Tonight's eviction is cancelled and Shabnam lives to fight another day. Instead of the eviction, and presumably to try and get over this and onto the next talking point, we've got two more men going in: one gay, one bi.
I bet Ziggy can't wait.